Critics of Protestantism/Expert Profile

Ask A Question


Although, as an American, I am a great admirer of the Protestant-influenced culture which created this country, as well as the zeal and Biblical scholarship of many Protestant denominations and individual Protestants, I am forced to conclude that the Protestant Faith is based on faulty and selective Biblical interpretation as well as erroneous reasoning. While Protestants can of course be good Christians, at its heart Protestantism is religious anarchy which will lead many devout souls to perdition. Jesus prayed that we may "all be one"(JN 17:21) and that there may be "one flock, one shepherd" (JN 10:16). I believe that He established a Church against which "the gates of Hell shall not prevail" (MT 16:18). I don't believe Jesus intended for Christianity to be an eternal debating club, which is the condition to which Sola Scriptura relegates our religion. I'll be glad to try to answer any questions you have, although my special interest is in the Faith/Works question, the question of the Bible's authority, and the dangers of Pentecostalism

Experience in the area

Lifetime interest in comparative religion, especially among Christians.

Average Ratings

Recent Reviews from Users

Read More Comments

    K = Knowledgeability    C = Clarity of Response    P = Politeness
Mike08/29/08101010Thank you so much Andrew, for your .....
Jana03/31/08101010Thank you very much for your answer .....
Mike02/04/08101010Thank you greatly Andrew, for your wonderfully .....
Doug08/29/07101010Good answer. I now know that I .....

Recent Answers from Andrew Foley

2013-12-11 bible:

Hello and thanks for your question. I do not, by an means, know everything about this subject but I will tell you what I know and what I believe, and we can discuss it. I guess there are three criteria

2012-03-23 bible question...:

Hello and thanks for writing. First of all, you ask too many questions. I can't possibly answer every single topic you bring up. I will try to address a few things.     First, the assertion that Jesus

2012-02-10 New Testament Prophets:

1st Corinthians 12:28-31 reads: 28 Some people God has designated in the church to be, first, apostles; 6 second, prophets; third, teachers; then, mighty deeds; then, gifts of healing, assistance, administration

2011-11-05 protestantism:

That theory can be traced to a very influential book by Max Weber called "The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism". It argues that Protestantism, or more specifically Calvinism, laid the psychological

2011-04-02 Protestant Sources of Religious Authority:

Sorry for taking so long to respond. In addition to the Bible and the Church, the only other major source of authority in Christian history has been the indwelling guidance of the Holy Spirit. This source


Ask A Question

Critics of Protestantism

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


©2017 All rights reserved.